Sunday, 1 November 2009


just heard someone say

they love violin

well violin is related by root to

2 english words -

violate and violence

it in an instrument which

creates screeching violence for the ears

and violates the listener

prime reason behind the horribleness of

western orchestra sound

replicated religiously by bollywood

in their own band/brand of annoyance

so-called carnatic music died

the day they started using the violin

what they are actually saying is that they love violence


they won't be able to

say the same so freely


firefox said...

it's strange that the violin has gained so much popularity.. it's an instrument whose most natural obvious sound easily causes pain to the listener.. the arduous technique of violin bowing is to try and beautify what naturally produces a pain howl..

Shahid said...

Who else but PT Could relate the musical Violin to Violence and Violate?

PT your thoughts are really out of the box.
You amaze me with what you write!!!

Jenn said...

With respect:

What if it is played out of love, for love?

The ego has no place, never struggled here?

There is beauty in this howl, no? The Divine is not pleased by a child who loves this violin—not because he or she was pressed to play—but simply because there is magic, and pain in simply in the ear of the be-listener?

PT - The Axis said...

love is a highly misused word
please refer to the 'love' blog
if it is love one would not want to violate anyways

beauty is also a misuderstood term
beauty is in divinity/perfection
something which is quite
explainable now in terms of sacred geometry, golden symmetry ...

ego is also another word used
without proper understanding

what you are saying jenn
is not at all coherent
it only serves to support
illusory unreality
through imprecision ...
it was evil demiurge's minions who came up with beauty in pain maxims

pinx said...

this is so brilliant ! no-one but You could bring to light the true nature of the violin ! "violate and violence" - really it is so true ! any honest listener will be able to admit to the unpleasant effect this instrument has on one's ears ! it definitely only finds its true calling when used as a soundtrack to a horror film !

really great how You bring in the bollywood angle too. and very poignant statement that so-called carnatic music died the day they started using violin.

You are a true luminary & the bringer of truth ! You state so plainly what others refuse to see !

I Bow !

asha said...

so compassionate of You to explain this and to address jenn's question with such clarity and significant education !! so scientific and factual !!

'if it is love one would not want to violate anyways' ... You always word things so simple so all can understand what is so true !

it is really a priviledge to have access to Your observations made from the most intelligent and Highest birdseye view of everything !

so Beautiful !! I bow !

amanda v said...

Your Piercing insight sets every fallacy straight. i bow. dhanyavad P. Narayan! Narayan!

P3AZ21 said...

Your insights are great !
Profound !

PsingulariTy said...

You are The Peaceful One

Science Spirituality said...

Wow you bring the dark into light so effortlessly... you bring the most ignored mistake and rectify it with your golden words!!

neelang tiwari said...

i bow

neelang tiwari said...

i bow

jganesh said...

You are so right and so phunny ! i bow !

Swati said...

Thank you for sharing your views and making me understand difference between the real music and screeching.

Your divine beauty is beyond my thoughts, Perspectives and imagination.

Your real divine music is what can make relieve one from Pain and can take into complete bliss.

! bow to you my Lord for your divine presence in my life !!!

veena iyengar said...

Oh My God..Violence=violins..never thought of it like this..
Again learning things from a different perspective..